2015 NAIA Baseball All-America First Team
| Position | First | Last | Year | School | Hometown |
| C | Jesse | Baker | Sr. | Edward Waters (Fla.) | Sebring, Fla. |
| C | Osvaldo | Gonzalez | Sr. | Bellevue (Neb.) | Miami, Fla. |
| 1B | Ty | Abbott | Sr. | Georgia Gwinnett | Milton, Ga. |
| 2B | Yariel | Gonzalez | Jr. | Oklahoma Baptist | San Sebastian, P.R. |
| SS | Clayton | Brandt | Sr. | MidAmerica Nazarene (Kan.) | Stewardson, Ill. |
| 3B | Ridge | Hoopi-Haslam | Sr. | Tennessee Wesleyan | Hilo, Hawaii |
| INF | Randy | Santiesteban | Sr. | Peru State (Neb.) | Hialeah, Fla. |
| DH | Keivan | Berges | So. | Northwood (Fla.) | Wellington, Fla. |
| OF | Jordan | Tescher | Sr. | Dickinson State (N.D.) | Beach, N.D. |
| OF | Orlando | Olivera+ | Sr. | Missouri Baptist | Miami, Fla. |
| OF | Chris | Madera | Sr. | Faulkner (Ala.) | Santo Domingo, D.R. |
| OF | Alex | Bautista | Sr. | Lindsey Wilson (Ky.) | Brooklyn, N.Y. |
| SP | Adam | Panayotovich | Sr. | St. Francis (Ill.) | Palos Park, Ill. |
| SP | Corey | Hale | Sr. | Mobile (Ala.) | Luverne, Ala. |
| SP | Adam | Hines | Jr. | LSU Alexandria (La.) | Bunkie, La. |
| SP | Kelvin | Rivas | Sr. | Oklahoma Baptist | Guaynabo, P.R. |
| RP | Tyler | Mark | Jr. | Concordia (Calif.) | Los Angeles, Calif. |
2015 Rawlings-NAIA Baseball Gold Glove Team
| Position | Player | School |
| C | Cam Firth | British Columbia |
| 1B | Alex Bush | Westmont (Calif.) |
| 2B | Mitch Huckabay | LSU Alexandria (La.) |
| 3B | Alex Montero | LSU Shreveport (La.) |
| SS | Jose Rojas | Vanguard (Calif.) |
| CF | Mitchell Esser | Concordia (Calif.) |
| LF | Demetrius Moorer | Point Park (Pa.) |
| RF | Bryan Hernandez | Southwest (N.M.) |
| P | Jordan Hackett | Our Lady of the Lake (Texas) |